Classic and essential movie reviews

Dead Poets Society: Finding Truth and Beauty in Rebellion and Individuality

drama
2:08
PG
1989

Review by Brandon Talks Movies on Jul 24, 2018

Oh captain, my captain.

The 80s were a time of great financial growth, but also great greed, and Generation X was getting old enough to have an opinion about it. Gen X started their own cultural movement in the 90s and basically torched every­thing to the ground, but it started with some general unease in the 80s. Dead Poets Society, directed by Peter Weir (The Truman Show, Witness) and starring Robin Williams and a host of young talent, makes an interesting statement to the emerging Gen X ideology by showing how their parents dealt with that same problem of greed and success at the detriment of truth and beauty in the 1950s. This is admittedly not a universal movie—it delves deeply into Romantic and Transcendentalist ideologies and appeals to lovers of old books more than the general population. But there’s a lot here that teenagers of any age will relate to. Whether you agree with Walt Whitman and Henry David Thoreau or not, there’s plenty to think about and plenty to like in this film.

The story is set in a boys prep school in the 1950s, with most students there hoping to get into Yale or Harvard when they graduate. These are not intellectuals, though—they’re the kind of phony rich kids Holden Caulfield railed against in Catcher in the Rye, at least to start. But a new English teacher, John Keating, opens their eyes to Romantic poetry, free thought, and individualism—much to the chagrin of the very conservative school administration. As the boys discover themselves in the pages of classic literature, they form a club to read together and live free: the Dead Poets Society. The boys quickly discover, though, that living free is not without risk or consequence. They also come to learn that the world is not kind to the dreamers who dare to think for themselves.

Sucking the marrow out of life doesn’t mean choking on the bone.

A lot of English majors will cite this as a favorite movie, and that’s for good reason. This film draws on the wisdom from past literature to teach us how to be alive today, taking on a double meaning as we see how the Beatniks embracing poetry in the 50s parallels Gen X embracing brutal realism in the 80s and 90s. This is a great film about old books. This was one of the big inspirations for me becoming an English major in college and studying the classics. (Ironically, in my studies, I discovered that I didn’t actually like the Romantics or the Transcendentalists all that much, and I preferred the Existentialists. But I digress.) And after re-watching this, I kind of want to go back and pick up some of the books I loved in my youth. There’s a lot of truth and beauty in the world, and this film follows in the footsteps of the Romantics in reminding us to appreciate all of it.

Don’t let that description fool you into thinking that this is a boring movie about old, dusty books, though. This is, at its heart, a comedy with plenty of funny moments to keep your attention through­out. Seeing these teenage boys learn to embrace beauty and live life to the fullest is entertaining and hilarious. It has some serious and even dark moments (what’s literature without a little tragedy?), but even in the midst of darkness, this film is uplifting and inspiring. Overall, I’m not a fan of inspirational movies because they tend to lose their grip on reality, but this one never goes too far into flight or fantasy. In fact, some of the dark moments keep it grounded and turn it into a bit of a cautionary tale. But this film will make you believe that there is beauty and goodness in the world, and that’s no small accomplishment.

Should I Watch Dead Poets Society?

Dead Poets Society came along at an interesting time, and the statement it makes is a bit ambiguous. Was it an affirmation of the growing angst in the 80s? An indictment of how Gen X was handling it? Or was it simply a reminder that the youth of the 80s were not the first ones to encounter that problem? I don’t think it’s entirely clear, and it’s probably a little bit of each of those things. But it’s a great comedy-drama that’s a breath of fresh air in a sea of over-the-top pseudo-inspirational films, irreverent comedies, and angry rants about the darker parts of society. They don’t make films like this anymore, and frankly, it’s been a long time since they have.

Movies Like Dead Poets Society

Academy Awards

Winner: Best Original Screenplay

Nominee: Best Picture, Best Actor, Best Director

Peter Weir1980scomedydrama

Cartoon version of Brandon

About Brandon

My name is Brandon, and I love movies. Not bad ones, though—just the good ones. I’m curating and reviewing a list of classic, essential-viewing, or just plain good movies from all decades, and I've been reviewing them since 2016. I also co-host Peculiar Picture Show, a podcast about movies and mental health and write about Dungeons & Dragons options, builds, and optimization.

More in 1980s

More in comedy

More in drama